Every car person has heard the story. Someone bought the last of something, parked it, and years later it sold for a million dollars.
So should you buy the next limited edition, wrap it in a cover and wait? We ran the numbers against the two most boring investments there are, a house and an index fund.
The answer isn't what the car forums want to hear.
The Million-Dollar Holden Story Is True. Sort Of.
The famous "last Commodore" story is actually three different cars blended together. All three are real.
The first is the red VFII SS-V Redline sold as the last Holden off the line. It cost about A$65,000 new and hammered for A$750,000 in January 2021. The twist is that GM kept an identical red car as the true last Holden, and it sits in a museum.
The second is the very last Falcon GT, GT-F number 500. It sold for A$236,100 at a 2014 charity auction, about three times its list price, and later changed hands privately for a rumoured A$1 million that was never confirmed.
The third is the HSV GTSR W1 Maloo, one of only four that HSV officially built, for its most loyal customers. One sold for a reported A$1.2 million in December 2025.
You couldn't have bought any of them
Those three cars crushed every other investment. But they were one of one, one of four, or sold at a charity auction.
The money was made on the way in. Whoever got a one-of-four car at list price won, and nobody else got the chance.
The Cars You Could Actually Buy
The W1 sedan is the better test. It cost A$169,990 new in 2017, around 300 were built, and anyone with the money could order one.
At the 2021 peak one hammered for A$750,000. By January 2024 a W1 sedan sold for A$362,888 with fees, so anyone who paid peak money lost more than half.
Now take the A$169,990 a buyer paid in 2017. In an ASX 200 index fund it would be worth roughly A$345,000 today. As a slice of an Adelaide house, it would be worth around A$361,000 plus about A$62,000 in rent.
The W1 sedan, at its last sale, is worth about A$363,000. Take off around A$40,000 of insurance and it loses to both.
The owner who said no to A$1.15 million
The W1 Maloo number 001 was bid to A$1.15 million in 2021 and didn't sell. It finally went for about A$1.2 million four years later.
That's roughly 1% a year for waiting. Over the same stretch, Australian shares rose about 36% and Adelaide housing about 54%.
The House That Pays You Rent
The house part of the story checks out. The median Adelaide house went from about A$458,000 in late 2017 to about A$978,000 in October 2026.
It also paid rent the whole time, roughly A$160,000 after costs. An index fund pays dividends too, about 4% a year on Australian shares over the last decade.
A collector car pays nothing. A car sitting in paid storage costs somewhere between 5% and 10% of its value every year. Every year it has to beat that gap before it has made you a cent.
The Legends Through the Same Maths
Take the Ferrari F40. It cost about $400,000 new in the US, and in August 2026 the car built for Lee Iacocca, with 320 miles, sold for $8.4 million, a record for a standard F40. That's 21 times its price.
That's a great result. It smashes a house, and it roughly kept pace with the share market's price. But an index fund pays dividends as well. Put the same $400,000 into the S&P 500 in 1990, the year US cars arrived, reinvest the dividends and it's worth about $18 million today.
So the best standard F40 ever sold made less than half what the boring fund did. A typical F40 sells for $3.5 million to $5.5 million, about 6% to 8% a year since new, against roughly 11% for shares. And that's before 35 years of insurance and servicing.
The same story repeats across the famous "investment" cars. Typical examples of the 300SL Gullwing, Porsche 959, BMW M1, Lexus LFA, Porsche 918, 2005 Ford GT and Carrera GT all lost to a plain index fund.
The cars that actually won
A few cars did beat everything. A 250 GTO that cost $18,000 in 1962 sold for $51.7 million in 2023, about 13.7% a year against 10.1% for shares.
A 649-mile Ferrari Enzo made $17.9 million in January 2026, and one paint-to-sample Gulf Blue Carrera GT made $6.7 million when a typical one makes less than half that.
Notice the pattern. The winners are individual cars, the one perfect example, not whole models.
And the ones that flopped
- Jaguar XJ220: £470,000 in 1992, £310,500 at auction in 2025.
- Mercedes SLR McLaren: $452,750 new in 2005, and still worth less than that 20 years later, with a typical 2025 sale around $395,000.
- Ferrari 456 GT: over $200,000 new in 1995, and a typical one now sells for under $100,000.
- Bugatti Veyron: about $1.2 million to $1.5 million new in 2006 and about $2.1 million in 2026. That's only 2% to 3% a year, while shares did about 11%.
The 1989 buyer
Buying at the top ruins even the best car. In the 1989 to 1990 boom, people paid fortunes for F40s and 250 GTOs, often with borrowed money.
The crash came within months. GTO prices didn't get back to their 1989 level until the late 2000s, and an F40 that changed hands for around £1 million in 1990 sold for £543,375 in 2014.
Those peak buyers have made about 2% to 4% a year over 36 years. The same money in the S&P 500 grew 40 to 45 times.
Drive It or Hide It?
Here's the question that matters for most of us. Say you buy a A$150,000 enthusiast car in 2016 and keep it ten years, growing at 4.5% a year, the ten-year average for blue-chip collector cars.
We assumed storage at A$112 a week, insurance at about 1.1% of value, A$2,000 a year in servicing and a 10% cost to sell. Here's where you end up before tax:
- Hidden in paid storage: about A$104,700.
- Hidden in your own garage: about A$163,000.
- Driven 2,500 km a year: about A$119,100, even after a 10% hit for the extra kilometres.
- ASX 200 index fund: about A$353,100, or around A$313,500 after capital gains tax.
- A slice of an Adelaide house with rent: about A$342,200.
Paid storage costs more than the miles do. Driving only loses to paid storage if the kilometres knock more than about 17% off the sale price.
Compared with your own garage, driving costs roughly A$1.75 a kilometre. That's the price of the fun, and for a hobby it's a pretty fair one.
Low miles only matter when they're almost zero
The big low-mileage premiums go to cars that are basically still new, under 1,000 miles. Once a car has been driven, a few thousand more kilometres barely move the price.
And cars that sit still slowly die. Seals dry out, fluids go off and fuel turns to varnish, so a tiny number on the odometer can be a warning sign, not a bonus.
Rowan Atkinson drove his McLaren F1 about 41,000 miles and crashed it twice. It was still offered for sale at £8 million in 2015, against a price of well under £1 million when he bought it.
The tax edge isn't enough
In Australia and the UK, gains on a private car aren't taxed. That's the car's one real advantage over a house or a share portfolio.
But you can't claim a loss either, and none of the running costs are deductible. A tax-free 4.5% is still well behind a taxed 9%.
The Verdict
Most cars are not investments. They're spending with a good resale value, and that's fine.
The real money goes to people who got the one-of-four car at list price, or bought before a boom and sold into it. Everyone paying full market price for a "future classic" is funding them.
So buy the car you love, at a price you can afford to own. Then drive it, and count every kilometre as the dollar or two it costs, not the profit it was never going to make.